MIMAH Logo

Solar Diesel Hybrid: Adding Solar to an Existing Generator

Author

Hisham Abdalla

Date Published

Illustration of a diesel generator set in an enclosure next to rows of solar panels, joined by a small controller box, with a sun above and a small figure standing by

Disclaimer: Research and analysis by the engineering team. Sources referenced below.

A solar diesel hybrid adds a PV array to a generator you already own, and the generator stays in charge. The set keeps setting voltage and frequency, the solar inverters follow it, and a fuel saver controller reads the generator's load and holds solar back so the set never drops below its minimum loading or takes power backwards. Without a battery, that minimum loading is the ceiling on how much solar the site can use.

Shops also sell "hybrid solar generators", which are battery boxes. This article is about the other thing: a site generator set with a PV array added around it. In the worked example below, a 90 kWp array on a 250 kVA set cuts one clear day's fuel by 35 percent while solar supplies 37 percent of the energy. The gap is the fuel an engine burns just to keep running, and it explains why fuel savings trail the solar share.

How Does a Solar and Generator Hybrid Work?

A PV inverter cannot make a grid. It needs one to follow. In a retrofit the diesel set makes the grid, and each inverter matches the voltage and frequency it finds. If the solar output exceeds the load, the surplus has nowhere to go but back into the generator.

So a controller sits between them. The IEA PVPS Task 9 report on integrating PV into diesel-dominated micro-grids describes the fuel save controller as a device that measures the generator's output and keeps it above the minimum load factor by curtailing the inverters over a data link. In an emergency it shuts the inverters down to protect the set from reverse power. The controller commands the PV side only, so the set's own controls carry on as before.

Our guide to hybrid solar systems covers the version built around a battery inverter, where the battery forms the grid. This article stays with the simpler retrofit that leaves the generators in place.

What Limits How Much Solar a Generator Can Take?

The first limit is minimum loading. A diesel engine run lightly for long periods glazes its cylinders and lets combustion products blow by into the oil. The IEA report says efficiency is very low below about 30 percent of rated power, and that the literature gives a typical minimum load factor of 40 percent of nameplate. Manufacturers differ, and yours governs. Our generator maintenance schedule covers what wet stacking does to an engine.

That leaves one inequality. At any moment, solar output may not exceed the site load minus the generator's minimum load. The IEA report does the same sum with the lowest demand at noon. For a 200 kW set held above 30 percent, the floor is 60 kW. If the daytime load is 120 kW, solar is capped at 60 kW whatever the array can produce.

A rule of thumb comes from a GIZ planning checklist for solar-diesel hybrids in the Philippines, published in 2015. Measured as PV peak power divided by the generator's nominal power, it says up to 20 percent can be connected without an extra control unit, because the diesel grid acts as a voltage source and nothing flows back. A fuel save controller allows up to 60 percent, which it puts at 600 kW of PV for each megawatt of generator. It adds that generators should stay above 30 percent of installed diesel capacity, and that with storage the solar share can reach 100 percent and beyond.

Take the cap from the lowest load. A site that averages 120 kW and dips to 90 kW at lunch has a lower cap at lunch, which is when the sun is highest. Get the interval log before you size anything.

What Does a Fuel Saver Controller Do?

It measures. Current transformers on the generator output feed the controller the real load on the set. The inverters' own meters are not enough, because the controller must see what the generator sees.

It limits. Each time the generator load nears its floor, the controller sends the inverters a lower power setpoint. The array's maximum power point tracking makes this easy: an inverter can simply stop short of the available power.

It protects. Reverse power is the worst case. If the load drops suddenly while solar is high, for instance when a large motor trips, the surplus is pushed back into the alternator, which then motors the engine. That trips the set at best and damages it at worst. The controller reacts, but a separate reverse power relay should still trip the set's breaker without depending on the controller, and the GIZ checklist lists reverse power protection among its safeguards. A trip on a single set blacks out the site, which is the better of the two outcomes.

A controller will not repair a stuck governor or a worn alternator. The set must be in good shape before it is asked to share.

Reverse Power, Clouds and Spinning Reserve

A cloud is a load step. When solar output falls from 60 kW to nothing within seconds, the generator has to pick up all 60 kW at once. On the 200 kW set in the example that is a 30 percent step. Whether the set holds frequency through it depends on its governor and engine, and manufacturers publish transient response data for the purpose. Ask for it.

The IEA report calls the spare capacity a running generator keeps online for sudden load spinning reserve. It points out that a PV hybrid needs more of it, to cover the loss of solar, and that if grid stability matters enough to hold the whole PV peak in reserve, the investment suffers badly. A battery can supply that reserve instead. Without one, cap solar below the point where a total cloud-out would overload the set or drag the frequency out of tolerance.

Three limits on solar added to a generator without a battery: minimum loading caps solar at the site load minus the minimum load, surplus solar can drive the alternator as a motor, and a cloud is a load step on the set

The three limits on solar added to a generator without a battery, and the usual answer to each. The 60 kW cap uses a 120 kW load and a 200 kW set held above 30 percent. Source: IEA PVPS Task 9 report T9-19:2019; GIZ solar PV-diesel hybrid planning checklist, 2015.

A Worked Example: 90 kWp on a 250 kVA Set

Take a set rated 250 kVA prime, which is 200 kW at 0.8 power factor. The Cummins data sheet for the C275 D5 gives its fuel use at one quarter, one half, three quarters and full prime load as 14.2, 25.8, 38.3 and 52.5 litres per hour. That is 50, 100, 150 and 200 kW. Between those points we draw straight lines. From 50 to 100 kW the set burns an extra 0.232 litres per kilowatt, and from 100 to 150 kW an extra 0.25.

Suppose the site load is a flat 120 kW from 07:00 to 17:00, kept flat so the sums stay visible. A real load wanders, and its lowest point sets the cap. Assume a minimum loading of 30 percent, so 60 kW. That is the value the IEA report used in its simulations, while noting that many manufacturers propose more, and the floor the GIZ checklist gives. Solar can therefore supply at most 120 minus 60 = 60 kW. The array in the example is 90 kWp, which is 45 percent of the set's 200 kW, inside the 60 percent the GIZ checklist gives for a fuel save controller without storage.

Assume a clear-day output from that array, hour by hour from 07:00, of 9, 27, 44, 58, 68, 72, 68, 58, 44 and 27 kW. We have set the peak at 80 percent of nameplate to cover heat and dust losses. Capped at 60 kW, the solar actually used is 9, 27, 44, 58, 60, 60, 60, 58, 44 and 27 kW, which totals 447 kWh. The cap bites at 11:00, 12:00 and 13:00. The array made 475 kWh, so 28 kWh, about 6 percent, is curtailed.

Without solar, the set carries 120 kW all ten hours. Fuel at 120 kW is 25.8 + 0.25 × 20 = 30.8 litres an hour, or 308.0 litres a day. With solar, the generator load each hour is 120 minus the solar used. The generator load runs 111, 93, 76, 62, 60, 60, 60, 62, 76 and 93 kW. At 111 kW it burns 25.8 + 0.25 × 11 = 28.55 litres an hour. At 60 kW it burns 14.2 + 0.232 × 10 = 16.52. Across the ten hours the fuel is 28.55, 24.18, 20.23, 16.98, 16.52, 16.52, 16.52, 16.98, 20.23 and 24.18 litres, which sums to 200.9.

The saving is 308.0 minus 200.9 = 107.1 litres, or 34.8 percent. Solar supplied 447 ÷ 1,200 = 37.25 percent of the energy. The set at 60 kW still burns 16.52 litres an hour, which is 54 percent of its 120 kW fuel use while carrying half the load, because an engine's fuel burn has a fixed part that solar does not remove.

Hour by hour for a clear day: solar used, generator load and fuel burn from 07:00 to 16:00, totalling 447 kWh of solar and 200.9 litres of fuel against 308.0 litres without solar

One clear day for 90 kWp on a 200 kW set with a flat 120 kW load and a 30 percent minimum loading. Fuel is interpolated between the data sheet points. Source: Cummins C275 D5 data sheet DS22-CPGK (prime rating); MIMAH engineering practice.

Now change one assumption. If the manufacturer's minimum loading is 40 percent, or 80 kW, the cap falls to 40 kW. Solar used drops to 343 kWh, the fuel to 225.0 litres, and the saving to 83.0 litres, or 26.9 percent. Ten points of minimum loading cost 24 litres a day.

All of this is arithmetic on assumed inputs for ten daylight hours on one clear day. It says nothing about the night, the cloudy days or any real site. For a yearly view, the IEA report simulated three sites and found fuel savings of 10 to at most 30 percent with a fuel save controller, and only 1 to 10 percent without one at lower solar shares.

When Does a Battery Earn Its Place?

Heavy curtailment is the first sign. In the example only 6 percent is lost, so a battery would not pay on that alone. If the cap throws away a third of the array's output, a battery turns that waste into evening energy.

Clouds are the second. The generator carries spinning reserve, and a battery can take the step instead, so the set can run closer to its efficient load.

The third is wanting the generator to stop. With a battery and a hybrid inverter holding the grid, the set can switch off for hours, and the GIZ checklist puts the achievable solar share at up to 100 percent and beyond when storage is included.

A large evening load is the fourth. Solar shifting is an energy-bound job, which our article on sizing commercial battery storage works through.

For a starting size, the IEA report offers a rule of thumb of a battery of about 30 percent of the maximum load, taking kWh as a fraction of peak kW. For a 120 kW peak that suggests about 36 kWh. Treat it as an opening estimate. It came from one simulated village in Nepal, was then applied to two other modelled sites, and assumed a battery price of 800 euros per kWh in 2019. In those sites a battery left the cost of electricity about the same or slightly lower, and allowed a higher share of renewable energy.

What to Survey on the Existing Set First

Fuel and load history. Two weeks of kW at 15-minute intervals and the fuel log, so the cap and the fuel curve come from your set. Our article on diesel generator fuel consumption shows how litres per hour follows load.

Minimum loading and transient data. The manufacturer's figure and the step load acceptance of the set.

Governor and controller. Does the set hold frequency at constant speed, and can its controller share data or take a signal from a fuel saver controller?

Number of sets. With several in parallel the controller needs to know which are running at midday, and the IEA sum uses the smallest of them. Our guide to generator sizing covers the loading arithmetic for one set or two.

Protection. Whether a reverse power relay exists, and where the PV will connect so the controller sees every kilowatt.

Condition. Hours run, oil analysis, and the maintenance record. A set that runs fewer hours still needs exercising under real load.

Six things to survey on an existing generator before adding solar: fuel and load history, minimum loading and transient data, governor and controller, number of sets, protection, and condition

What to find out about the existing generator set before sizing the array. Source: MIMAH engineering practice.

What Is the First Step?

Log the load for two weeks. Get the manufacturer's minimum loading and transient data. Subtract the minimum loading from the lowest daytime load to find the solar cap, then size the array so its clear-day peak sits near that cap, a little over if the shoulders justify it. Specify the controller and an independent reverse power relay in the same package. Leave the battery out until a season of data shows how much solar is curtailed and how often clouds hurt.

We would not connect a PV array to a generator with no controller and no reverse power relay, however small the ratio looks on paper.

A retrofit like this is where both sides of MIMAH meet. The renewable energy team designs hybrid systems with battery storage, and the maintenance team looks after rotating equipment. If you have a set and a daytime load and want to know what a solar array could take, get in touch.