MIMAH Logo

Turbine Borescope Inspection: What It Can See and What It Cannot

Author

Hisham Abdalla

Date Published

Illustration of a simple steam turbine casing with a thin cyan probe line entering through a small port, and a small engineer standing beside it

Disclaimer: Research and analysis by the engineering team. Sources referenced below.

A borescope inspection passes a small camera on a probe through an existing port or opening, so the inside of a turbine can be seen without lifting the casing. It shows the surfaces within reach of the probe tip: erosion, deposits, nicks, missing pieces and rub marks. It does not show blade roots inside their attachments, tight or subsurface cracks, or clearances.

That split decides everything else. A borescope (also spelled boroscope) is usually the cheapest way to find out whether a turbine needs opening, and a poor way to prove it does not. Below are the tools, the access points, the preparation, what to record, and how to turn the findings into a decision. The damage mechanisms themselves are in our guide to steam turbine blade damage.

Rigid, Flexible and Articulating Scopes: Which One Reaches a Turbine?

Remote visual inspection is the formal name for this kind of work, and the borescope is its main tool. The Evident guide to remote visual inspection sorts the instruments simply. Rigid scopes suit straight-line access. Flexible video scopes suit curved paths. Articulation, usually two-way or four-way, lets the operator steer the tip, and an optional measurement feature gives a size for a defect instead of an opinion.

For turbines, the choice follows the route to the blades. A rigid scope can be pushed through a straight port in a casing. A flexible scope is needed when the path bends, but a flexible tube has little stiffness. A 2004 case in Nuclear Engineering International, described below, likens working a conventional videoscope through blade rows from the condenser to "pushing a rope". It reached about two rows.

My view is that nobody should buy or hire a scope before looking at the drawings. Port positions, port diameters and the straightness of the route decide which instrument can work, and picture quality comes second to whether the tip can reach the surface at all.

Where the Access Points Are on a Steam Turbine

Gas turbines are built for this. GE's maintenance guide for its heavy-duty gas turbines, GER-3620-P, describes radially aligned holes through the compressor casings, the turbine shell and the internal stationary shrouds. They give a view of intermediate compressor stages, the first three turbine bucket stages and the nozzle partitions. The guide recommends a borescope inspection at each combustion inspection or annually, whichever comes first, on gas and distillate fuel, and says the aim is to do as much of the major inspection scope as possible without disassembly.

Steam turbines are less standard, and access depends on the design and on what the maker provided. The two published cases used here are examples, not a survey, but both show access being worked out from the drawings or improvised. In a 2017 POWER article by Bryan Grant, casing drawings showed four borescope ports, and a review of the system drawings then turned up a threaded pipe plug on the low pressure crossover elbow. Crews erected scaffolding, stripped insulation, and put a scope through the elbow to see the low pressure flow divider and first-stage nozzles. In the 2004 case, the route was through the condenser.

The practical point is that the drawings, not the scope, define what can be seen. Before an outage, list every port and plug on the casing and the connecting pipework, say which stage each one serves, and say which stages have no route at all, because the report will have to flag those as not inspected.

Gas turbines have purpose-built radial borescope holes, while steam turbine access came from drawings, pipe plugs and the condenser in two published cases

How borescope access differs between a gas turbine and a steam turbine. Source: GE Vernova GER-3620-P; POWER (2017); Nuclear Engineering International (2004).

Preparing the Turbine: Cooling, Isolation and Permits

A port plug is a pressure boundary. Steam must be isolated and proved off, the unit locked out, any vacuum broken, and the casing cool enough to work on before anything is unscrewed. The permit should name the person who can reinstate the plug and the test that proves it tight afterwards. A route through the condenser, as in the 2004 case, is also a confined space entry with its own permit.

Count everything that goes in and comes out: probes, guide tubes, plugs and tools. Anything left behind is the foreign object the next inspection will be looking for.

Cooling needs care. GE's gas turbine guide treats cool-down as complete only when all wheelspace temperatures are below 150°F (about 66°C) at turning gear speed. It also warns against speeding cool-down by opening compartment doors or lagging panels, because uneven cooling of the outer casing can distort it and cause heavy blade rubs. That is guidance for GE gas turbines, and your steam turbine's instruction book governs, but the physics carries over. Strip insulation at the port you need, not along the casing.

Rotation needs a plan too. To see every blade in a row, the rotor has to be turned past the port, and a rotor that stops turning while hot can bow. Grant's article describes a unit whose turning gear failed to engage, so the rotor cooled while stationary, bowed, and had to be sent off site for straightening. If the borescope plan relies on turning the rotor, agree in advance who turns it, how far, and how the position is recorded, and keep the probe tip clear of the moving row while it turns.

Last, fix the numbering before the scope goes in. Agree how stages, rows and blades are counted, from which end, and which direction is positive, so the next report can match every blade to the drawing.

What to Look For, Section by Section

For each section of the steam path, the useful record is where damage starts and stops, how it compares with last time, and whether it is changing.

Inlet stages, high pressure and intermediate. Nozzle trailing edges and first-stage leading edges show particle erosion first. Record the extent along each edge instead of the single word "erosion", so that the next inspection can measure change. Note deposit colour and texture, and any weld debris or loose parts.

Middle stages. Look at shroud bands and lashing for gaps, buckling or missing segments, at tip areas for rub marks, and at deposit build-up that narrows the passages. A missing shroud segment is a mass loss, which changes the rotor's balance and shows up in the vibration trend.

Last low pressure stages. Leading-edge erosion towards the tip, and whether it has passed the protected zone, is the main question. These stages are also the hardest to reach.

Diaphragms and seals. Partition trailing edges near a port are usually visible. Seal teeth that have been rubbed show a mushroomed tip, if the teeth are in view. In the 2017 POWER case the absence of that mushrooming ruled out a rub, though that check was made with the casing open. The real fault was seal caulking wire that had worked out of its groove, and the borescope found one piece lodged in a first-stage low pressure nozzle. Material that comes loose upstream travels downstream, so look past the stage that failed.

Crossovers and exhausts. Loose seal material, scale and debris collect here, and any you find has come from somewhere upstream.

For the mechanisms behind these findings, see our steam turbine inspection checklist. Our guide to steam turbine diaphragm repair covers what to do when a diaphragm is damaged.

What a Borescope Cannot See

A clean result clears only the surfaces in view, as our blade damage guide sets out. The usual blind spots are blade roots inside their attachments, tight cracks that close up at standstill, anything beneath the surface, clearances, and deposit chemistry. Those need non-destructive testing or measurement with the casing open.

The 2004 Nuclear Engineering International case shows how far a first look can fall short. A 321 MW cross-compound unit, with 13-stage low pressure sections and 44 inch last-stage blades, developed rising vibration in one low pressure section. A conventional videoscope worked from inside the condenser reached only about two blade rows. An articulated manipulator with more axial stiffness, from work involving EPRI, went past nine or ten rows and found a missing shroud band segment with buckled bands beside it. The Nuclear Engineering International article says that when the casing was opened, the damage covered three blade rows and not one, and the outage ran about two weeks longer than planned. It also says that the utility inspected early and could order spares at normal lead times, and that having replacement blades for the worst-hit row on hand likely cut at least five weeks from the outage.

Two lessons come from that. A borescope can find a fault early enough to order parts at normal lead times. And its first finding is a minimum, so plan for more when the casing opens.

A borescope sees erosion, deposits, nicks, missing pieces and rub marks, but not blade roots inside attachments, tight cracks, subsurface flaws, clearances or deposit chemistry

What a borescope inspection can and cannot show. A clean result clears only the surfaces in view. Source: MIMAH engineering practice.

Reporting a Borescope Inspection So the Next One Can Use It

A useful report ties every image to a location a stranger can find again: stage, row, blade number, port used, insertion depth or rotor position, and which edge of the blade. It includes a scale reference in the frame where the instrument allows measurement, and the instrument and probe used, so the next crew can repeat the view.

Then it says what changed. Compare each finding with the same view at the last inspection and state the date of that inspection. A leading edge that looks mildly eroded tells you little. The same edge, photographed from the same port at the same rotor position two years ago and now eroded over a longer length, gives you a rate.

The report should also say what was not seen: which stages had no access, which blades could not be turned into view, and which images are poor. That list defines the remaining risk. Classify each finding as monitor, repair at the next outage, or act now, and state the reason in one line. Our inspection checklist covers the same discipline for open inspections.

Open the Casing or Leave It Shut?

Treat the borescope as a filter that can say yes more reliably than it can say no.

Open the casing when the scope finds a confirmed rub, a missing or broken part, a shroud failure, damage on more than one row, or anything that looks like a crack. Open it too when a clean scope result sits beside a vibration step or a performance loss that the scope cannot explain, since the roots and the clearances remain unchecked.

Leave it shut when the scope finds only minor, stable wear that matches the previous inspection, the running data is steady, and the stages with no access have no reason for concern. In that case the borescope can legitimately defer an opening, provided the OEM's interval and your insurer's conditions allow it.

Use it to prepare the opening when you are going to open the casing anyway. Findings arrive early enough to order blades, diaphragms or seals before the outage, as the 2004 case shows. Our guide to steam turbine overhaul cost explains how to budget the base scope plus a contingency for what the opening finds, and the steam path audit article covers how the findings fit with efficiency losses.

Three outcomes of a borescope inspection: open the casing, leave it shut, or use the findings to prepare an opening you are making anyway

How to turn borescope findings into a decision. The scope can say yes more reliably than it can say no. Source: MIMAH engineering practice.

What Does a Borescope Inspection Cost?

A fair price can only be set after the scope of the visit is known, and no honest figure applies to every turbine. Access drives most of it: how many ports there are, whether plugs and insulation have to be removed, and whether scaffolding is needed. The instrument comes next, since a straight rigid scope is simpler than a steerable manipulator that reaches deep stages. Then there is time on site, including turning the rotor and recording positions, and the report, which may be images only or may include measurements, comparisons and recommendations. Mobilisation is where an emergency call differs most from a planned visit, because crews and instruments have to be found and moved at short notice.

Compare the cost with days, not with the inspection's own price. Suppose, purely as a hypothetical input, a 30 MW unit running at full load earns a margin of $40 per MWh. Each day offline costs 30 MW x 24 h x $40 per MWh = $28,800 of lost margin. If an unplanned opening runs two weeks over, as in the 2004 case, that is 14 days x $28,800 = $403,200, before any repair work. Set against that, a borescope visit that avoids one unnecessary opening, or brings a spare part forward by weeks, is unlikely to be the item to economise on. Use your own load and tariff in place of these numbers.

What to Do Next

If you have a steam turbine with an unexplained vibration step, a performance loss or an overdue internal look, list the ports and the plugs first, then decide what the borescope has to answer. Ask for a plan that names the stages it will reach and the stages it will not. Ask for a report that compares each finding with the last inspection, states what was not seen, and gives a decision for each item.

MIMAH's rotating equipment team is independent of any one turbine manufacturer, and our work covers outage work, performance diagnostics and root cause analysis. If you want a second view on a borescope report, or help scoping one before an outage, get in touch.