Solar PPA vs Lease: Which Suits a Commercial Site
Author
Hisham Abdalla
Date Published

Disclaimer: Research and analysis by the engineering team. Sources referenced below. The worked example uses hypothetical inputs, not market quotes. Tax, accounting and legal points are general information, not advice: take advice from your auditor, tax adviser and lawyer.
In a solar PPA you pay for each kilowatt hour the system delivers. In a solar lease you pay a fixed rent whatever it delivers. That one difference decides who carries the performance risk: under a PPA the owner does, under a lease you do, and a fair price for the same system should reflect it.
A PPA suits a site with a variable or seasonal load, or a buyer who cannot judge a yield model. A lease suits a stable daytime load, a buyer who can check the engineering, and a lessor that guarantees production. If you have the cash and can run the plant, buying usually costs less than either.
Our solar PPA guide explains how a PPA works, our article on commercial solar financing in Africa compares the funding routes, and our piece on solar PPA rates shows how a tariff is built. Here we put the PPA and the lease side by side and work one hypothetical through a poor year.
Pay per kWh or Pay a Fixed Rent
Both are third-party ownership: a third party owns, installs and operates the system and either sells you the power or rents you the system. An appendix by NREL authors in the US EPA's Guide to Purchasing Green Power describes the PPA as a sale of electricity, usually per kilowatt hour, over a fixed term. A 2009 NREL checklist puts PPA contracts at 15 to 25 years. The EPA appendix describes the lease as a monthly rate for a pre-set period, typically 10 to 20 years, with the fixed payment as its defining feature and an annual escalator typical. Because the payment is fixed, it adds, leases usually carry a production guarantee, and the lessee assumes the performance risk.
The word lease hides two different products. In the appendix's US tax terms, an operating lease leaves the lessor as owner and tax claimant and is structured on the assumption that you will not necessarily own the system later. A capital or finance lease behaves like a purchase on instalments and is built for you to end up the owner. The balance sheet side of that distinction has moved on since the appendix was written, as the accounting section below explains. Ask which one you are being offered before comparing anything else.
A Poor Year, Side by Side
Take a hypothetical 100 kWp rooftop system expected to produce 1,700 kWh per kWp a year, or 170,000 kWh, all of it used on site. The PPA tariff is a flat $0.090 per kWh, so a normal year costs 170,000 x 0.090 = $15,300. The lessor sets the rent at the same $15,300 a year, $1,275 a month, which makes the two equal in a normal year. Assume a full-service lease where the lessor maintains the system. The avoided cost of grid or diesel power is $0.20 per kWh. These are inputs picked for the arithmetic, not quotes.
Now run three years. A normal year delivers 170,000 kWh, avoids 170,000 x 0.20 = $34,000 of grid or diesel cost, and saves $18,700 net under either contract. A poor year delivers 10 percent less, 153,000 kWh. A good year delivers 6 percent more, 180,200 kWh.
In the poor year the PPA bill falls to 153,000 x 0.090 = $13,770, while the rent stays $15,300. The lease now costs 15,300 / 153,000 = $0.100 per kWh instead of $0.090. The avoided cost is 153,000 x 0.20 = $30,600, so the net saving is $16,830 under the PPA and $15,300 under the lease, a difference of $1,530. In the good year the PPA bill rises to $16,218 and the lease costs $0.0849 per kWh. The net saving is $19,822 under the PPA and $20,740 under the lease, so the lease wins by $918.

A hypothetical 100 kWp roof under a PPA at $0.090 per kWh and a lease at $15,300 a year, through a poor, a normal and a good year. Source: MIMAH engineering practice.
A 10 percent shortfall is large for weather alone. PVsyst's documentation puts typical year-to-year variability of annual irradiation at 3 to 4 percent. To lose 10 percent you would need weather, a month of inverter downtime and a neglected cleaning schedule together. Under a full-service lease the last two are the lessor's to prevent, yet the rent does not fall, which is why the guarantee matters.
So add a production guarantee to the lease. Suppose the lessor guarantees 95 percent of expected output, 161,500 kWh, and credits any shortfall at the PPA price. In the poor year the shortfall is 161,500 - 153,000 = 8,500 kWh, a credit of 8,500 x 0.090 = $765. The lease saving rises to $16,065, still $765 behind the PPA.
A design fault is the bigger exposure, because it comes back every year. Suppose the plant delivers 8 percent less than modelled, from shading nobody checked or a yield model that was too optimistic. Under the PPA you pay for the energy you get, and your price per kWh does not move. Under the lease you pay full rent for 13,600 kWh you never receive, which is 13,600 x 0.090 = $1,224 a year, and $12,017 over 20 years at 8 percent (annuity factor 9.8181, degradation ignored). The 95 percent guarantee would hand back only $459 of that each year, on the 5,100 kWh below its floor. A lease makes the quality of the yield model your problem, so that model deserves an independent check before you sign.
This is also why a rent equal to the PPA's normal-year bill is not a neutral offer. It pays you nothing for taking on these risks, so a fair rent should sit below it.
One point runs the other way. You pay nothing when the system produces nothing only if the cause is on the owner's side. If the cause is yours, such as a plant shutdown or refused site access, a deemed energy clause can bill you for what the system would have produced.
Who Carries Maintenance, Insurance and the Equipment
Under a PPA the developer normally operates and maintains the system and replaces failed equipment. The EPA appendix calls this historically a primary selling point of third-party ownership, while noting that stand-alone O&M packages now let owners buy that service separately. The 2009 NREL checklist says insurance is generally the system owner's too, with the cost built into the price of the electricity.
Under a lease the split depends on the contract. A full-service lease puts maintenance and replacement on the lessor. A net lease puts them on you, usually with the insurance, and the rent should then be lower. Compare rents only after adding your own O&M cost to a net lease. Our O&M contract guide sets out what that cost buys.
Warranties sit with the owner in both cases, so you are relying on someone else to claim. A lessee should still ask for a copy of each of the four layers set out in our guide to solar PV warranties.

Who carries what under a PPA and under a lease. Source: US EPA, Guide to Purchasing Green Power, Appendix B, Commercial Solar Financing Options (NREL authors); MIMAH engineering practice.
Accounting and Tax: Take Advice
These rules vary more by country than anything else in the comparison, so treat this section as pointers.
Older guides describe operating leases and PPAs as off balance sheet, and the EPA appendix does, on US material from around 2017. Do not read that as a current rule. IFRS 16, effective for periods beginning on or after 1 January 2019, gives lessees a single model: a right-of-use asset and a lease liability for leases longer than 12 months, unless the asset is of low value. If you report under full IFRS, do not assume a rent contract stays off your balance sheet.
Smaller companies may sit under different rules. The third edition of the IFRS for SMEs standard chose not to align with IFRS 16, and US GAAP has its own lease standard, ASC 842. Your reporting framework decides the answer.
A PPA can itself contain a lease. KPMG's 2021 note on IFRS 16 says that turns on whether the buyer directs the use of the plant. Where it does and the payment is per unit generated, all payments are variable, so the buyer recognises a liability only if it has committed to a fixed minimum purchase. A take or pay clause can therefore touch the accounts as well as the price. Whether your contract falls on one side of that line is a question for your auditor, using your contract and your framework.
Tax often follows ownership. Writing about the US, the EPA appendix says third-party owners keep the tax benefits in a PPA and in an operating lease, while under a capital lease the lessee is the owner for tax. It also notes that tax-exempt buyers can gain when the owner passes a benefit on in a lower price. Rules differ by country and change, so confirm locally which party can claim any allowance and whether the pricing reflects it.
Credit, Security and What Happens if the Site Closes
Both structures lend against your promise to pay. The EPA appendix notes that buyers with poor credit or no credit history find PPAs and loans harder to secure and may face higher interest rates, and it lists good credit among the traits of buyers who benefit most from leases. Expect a deposit or a guarantee if your balance sheet is thin. The underwriting logic is the one set out in our PPA guide.
Closing the site does not end the obligation under either. The 2009 NREL checklist describes a PPA buyout set at the greater of fair market value or a termination value, which often includes the present value of the electricity the system would have generated over the remaining term. Expect a lease to set its termination sum by reference to the rent still to come. Ask for the termination amounts as a schedule by year, because the early years cost the most.
Check whether the contract can transfer to a buyer of the building, and whether your landlord must consent. The EPA appendix flags the mismatch between building lease terms of, say, 6 to 8 years and a solar asset life of 20 years or more.
End of Term
The 2009 NREL checklist lists three outcomes for a PPA at the end: buy the system at fair market value, extend the PPA, or have the owner remove it. An operating lease usually ends in a return or a purchase at a price still to be agreed. A finance lease is normally built to end with you as owner, but read the clause, because the label does not settle title.
What separates a good contract from a bad one here is whether the end of term price is a number, a formula or an argument. Fair market value is an argument. Ask for a fixed price or a stated formula, and for who pays to remove the array and reinstate the roof.
Which Fits Which Business
Choose the PPA if your daytime load is variable or seasonal, you have no engineer to test a yield model, or you want the performance risk to rest with the party that designed the plant. You accept a higher effective price per kWh in return.
Choose the lease if your daytime load is stable and larger than the system output, an independent engineer can check the yield model, and the lessor guarantees production. Either you run the O&M or the lease is full-service. In return you should get a lower effective price in a normal year, and a fixed budget.
Buy if you have the capital and the technical capacity. The EPA appendix reports modelled cost of energy for a commercial system financed by a loan below the same system under a PPA, because of the higher cost of capital behind a PPA. That is US modelling under US tax rules, but the logic travels: the owner's return is built into the tariff. You then carry the performance risk yourself. If you are weighing an owned system against diesel, our solar payback calculator gives a first estimate.
Walk away from a lease with no production guarantee, no maintenance cover and no purchase price at the end. That is a loan on equipment you will not own.

A rule for choosing between a solar PPA, a lease and a purchase. Source: MIMAH engineering practice.
If you hold offers for both structures, ask each bidder for the yield model, the degradation assumption and the sizing, then run the poor year and the design fault through both. MIMAH's renewable energy team reviews the engineering beneath PPA and lease offers, and you can get in touch with the offers you hold.
