MIMAH Logo

Insulation Resistance Testing for Motors and Generators

Author

Hisham Abdalla

Date Published

Illustration of an electric motor on a baseplate with a portable insulation tester connected by two leads and an engineer standing beside it with a clipboard

Disclaimer: Research and analysis by the engineering team. Limits quoted are those published for IEEE Std 43-2000 and should be checked against the edition your machine maker or contract names. Sources referenced below.

An insulation resistance test, often called a megger test, applies a direct voltage between a machine's winding and its frame and reads the leakage in megohms. On a modern form-wound AC winding at 40 degrees C, IEEE Std 43-2000 as Megger reproduces it sets a minimum of 100 MΩ after one minute. For random-wound stators and form-wound coils rated below 1 kV the minimum is 5 MΩ. The polarization index, the 10-minute reading divided by the 1-minute reading, should be at least 2.0 for insulation of thermal class B, F or H.

Those are floors, not targets, and one reading proves little. This article covers what the test measures, how to pick a test voltage, how to judge a result, how to correct for temperature, how to run it safely and what it cannot find. It is about rotating machine windings: turbine generators, diesel alternators and motors.

What a Megger Test Actually Measures

When the test voltage goes on, three currents flow. A capacitive current charges the winding and dies away in seconds. An absorption current, from the insulation polarising, decays over minutes. A leakage current, through and over the surface of the insulation, stays roughly constant. Megger's guide describes the same three components (Megger, A Guide to Diagnostic Insulation Testing Above 1 kV).

The resistance is the test voltage divided by the total current. Dry, clean insulation lets the first two currents fade, so the reading climbs through the test. Damp or dirty insulation passes a steady leakage current, and the reading stays low and flat.

That is why the polarization index works. Dividing the 10-minute reading by the 1-minute reading compares how fast the current is falling. A ratio near 1 says leakage dominates. A ratio of 2 or more says the insulation is absorbing and then settling, which is what dry insulation does.

Which Test Voltage for Which Machine?

The voltage follows the winding rating. The values below are the ones Megger reproduces from IEEE Std 43-2000 for DC voltage applied during the test, with the winding rating taken as the line-to-line voltage of a three-phase machine. A winding rated below 1,000 V gets 500 V. A 1,000 to 2,500 V winding gets 500 to 1,000 V, a 2,501 to 5,000 V winding gets 1,000 to 2,500 V, and a 5,001 to 12,000 V winding gets 2,500 to 5,000 V. Above 12,000 V the test is 5,000 to 10,000 V.

DC test voltage by winding rated voltage: 500 V below 1,000 V, 500 to 1,000 V for 1,000 to 2,500 V, 1,000 to 2,500 V for 2,501 to 5,000 V, 2,500 to 5,000 V for 5,001 to 12,000 V, and 5,000 to 10,000 V above 12,000 V

Insulation resistance test voltage by winding rated voltage, as reproduced by Megger from IEEE Std 43-2000. Source: Megger, A Guide to Diagnostic Insulation Testing Above 1 kV.

The standard covers machines of 750 W and above, and does not apply to fractional horsepower machines. Pick a voltage inside the band for the winding, and use the lower end when the winding may be damp. Megger warns that wet insulation can break down even at low voltage, so apply a high test voltage to a damp machine only with great care.

What Is a Good Megger Reading?

Look at the figures as a pair: an insulation resistance and a polarization index.

Minimum insulation resistance at 40 degrees C after one minute. Megger's table gives the rated machine voltage in kV plus 1 MΩ for most windings made before about 1970, all field windings and others not listed below. It gives 100 MΩ for most DC armatures and AC windings built after about 1970 with form-wound coils, and 5 MΩ for most machines with random-wound stator coils and form-wound coils rated below 1 kV.

Minimum polarization index. 1.5 for thermal class A insulation and 2.0 for classes B, F and H.

Whole winding or one phase. Those minimums are for the entire winding. Megger says one phase tested with the other two grounded should read about twice the whole winding figure, and three times if the other phases are guarded.

Which test must pass. For machines of 10,000 kVA or less, either the insulation resistance or the polarization index should exceed its minimum. Above 10,000 kVA, both should.

When the polarization index stops meaning anything. Howard Penrose, writing in Reliability magazine, notes that the 2000 edition applies the PI ratios only when insulation resistance is below 5,000 MΩ (Penrose, Insulation Testing in Transition). His EC&M article quotes the standard on the same point: above 5,000 MΩ at one minute, the calculated PI may not be meaningful (A Review of Polarization Index and IEEE Std. 43-2000).

A quick example. Suppose a class F winding in the 100 MΩ class reads 300 MΩ at one minute, corrected to 40 degrees C, and 780 MΩ at ten. The PI is 780 / 300 = 2.6, above 2.0, and 300 MΩ is above 100 MΩ, so it passes both. A second winding reads 40 MΩ and 44 MΩ. Its PI is 44 / 40 = 1.1 and its resistance is under 100 MΩ, so it fails both and should be cleaned and dried before anyone applies a higher voltage.

Reading the ratio. Megger's own guide to interpretation is below 1 poor, 1 to 2 questionable, 2 to 4 okay and above 4 good. It also notes that a PI above 5 can point to brittle or cracked insulation, and that a sudden rise of more than 20 percent with no maintenance should be treated as a warning.

Minimum insulation resistance values of kV plus 1 megohm, 100 megohms and 5 megohms by winding type, minimum polarization index of 1.5 for class A and 2.0 for classes B, F and H, and which test must pass by machine size

Recommended minimums after one minute at 40 degrees C, and polarization index by thermal class. Source: Megger, A Guide to Diagnostic Insulation Testing Above 1 kV, reproducing IEEE Std 43-2000.

Which Edition Applies?

The latest published edition is IEEE Std 43-2013, published in March 2014. IEEE now lists it as inactive-reserved, with the status dated 21 March 2024, and shows a project, P43, to revise it (IEEE Std 43-2013 page). We have not seen the 2013 text, which is paywalled, so the numbers above are those published for the 2000 edition.

Penrose reports that the 2013 edition changed some things: the DC armature entry was dropped from the 100 MΩ class, and temperature correction now depends on the type of insulation system instead of a fixed 10 degrees C step. If a contract, a motor repair specification or an insurer names an edition, work to that one.

Temperature Correction, With a Worked Example

Insulation resistance falls as temperature rises, so every reading needs correcting to 40 degrees C before it is compared with a minimum or with last year's value. Megger's rule of thumb, for use when no better data exists, is that resistance halves for every 10 degrees C of temperature rise and doubles for every 10 degrees C of fall. Its example is 100 GΩ at 20 degrees C becoming 25 GΩ at 40 degrees C. The formula is R(40) = R(T) x 0.5^((40 - T) / 10).

Megger also prefers manufacturers' correction tables, or a curve built by testing the same machine at two temperatures. Treat the rule as an approximation.

Take a hypothetical 3.3 kV form-wound motor from 2005. It sits in the 100 MΩ class, and a test voltage within the 1,000 to 2,500 V band applies. Two one-minute readings of the whole winding, a year apart:

First test, winding at 45 degrees C: 150 MΩ. Corrected, 150 x 0.5^((40 - 45) / 10) = 150 x 1.414 = 212 MΩ.

Second test, winding at 15 degrees C: 400 MΩ. Corrected, 400 x 0.5^((40 - 15) / 10) = 400 x 0.1768 = 71 MΩ.

The raw reading went up from 150 to 400 MΩ and looks like an improvement. Corrected to the same temperature, it fell from 212 MΩ to 71 MΩ, below the 100 MΩ minimum. A cold winding flatters the number. The polarization index is less sensitive. Megger treats it as normally independent of temperature, because a machine's thermal mass holds it steady over ten minutes. Penrose's EC&M article reads the 2000 edition more strictly: above the dew point, corrected to 40 degrees C, and for a trend, at about the same winding temperature each time. Test at a similar temperature and you satisfy both.

A worked temperature correction: a reading of 150 megohms at 45 degrees C corrects to 212 megohms at 40 degrees C, while a reading of 400 megohms at 15 degrees C corrects to 71 megohms, below the 100 megohm minimum

A hypothetical 3.3 kV form-wound motor tested a year apart: the raw reading rose but the corrected reading fell below the minimum. Source: Megger rule of thumb for temperature correction; MIMAH engineering practice.

How to Run the Test Safely

Follow the site's lockout and permit procedure first. A test set can put up to 10 kV on the winding, so barrier the machine and warn anyone working on the same circuit. Then, in this order:

Isolate and prove dead. Open and lock the supply, and prove the winding is dead with a voltage tester rated for the machine.

Ground and discharge. Ground the winding before anyone touches a terminal, and discharge any capacitors connected to it. Megger calls a fully discharged winding the first step in any insulation test.

Disconnect external equipment. The standard calls for cables, capacitors and surge arresters to be disconnected and grounded because they change the reading. Disconnect the motor leads from a variable frequency drive, and on a brushless alternator disconnect the AVR and isolate the rotating diodes as its manual directs, so no electronics stay in the test circuit.

Check dew point. The machine should be above the dew point, or condensation will distort the reading. Write down winding temperature and humidity.

Test each phase separately if possible. Ground the phases not under test to the same ground as the stator core. Testing all three together measures only insulation to ground.

Run the test. Lift the ground only from the phase under test and keep everyone clear of the terminals. Run one minute for the spot reading and ten for the polarization index, with the same voltage and connections each time.

Discharge. The insulation holds charge after the test. Let the tester discharge the winding and wait until it shows a safe voltage. Megger's rule of thumb is to discharge for five times as long as the test lasted, so 50 minutes after a 10-minute PI.

Short and ground the terminals. Stored absorption charge can build back up to a dangerous voltage if the terminals are left open, so keep them shorted and grounded until the machine goes back into service.

Trend the Readings, Do Not Judge One

A single megohm figure depends on temperature, humidity, the tester's range and the length of the test. A slow decline over years at a consistent temperature is the real signal. Megger's guide makes the same point: a machine with a low but steady reading can be healthier than one with a high reading that is diving. Record the voltage used, the winding temperature, the 1-minute and 10-minute values, the PI and the date, and file them with the machine's history. Run it like any other trend in a condition monitoring programme, with an owner and a date for the next reading.

Moisture, Contamination and Drying Out

Low readings often mean moisture or dirt on the winding, not failed insulation, and cleaning or drying can raise them. Megger's first choice for drying is an oven with temperature control and air circulation, with infrared lamps or a heated enclosure where that is not possible. It advises that when circulating low-voltage current through a winding to dry it, the insulation resistance should first have reached at least 100 MΩ, the current should be a fraction of nameplate, and winding temperature should not exceed 90 degrees C. It also says to continue drying until readings are reliable, since the curve often dips before it levels off. Keep the drying record: it shows when the winding is truly dry, and a flooded motor reading 15 MΩ may be fine or still wet depending on its past values.

What the Test Does Not Find

Insulation resistance and PI describe leakage from the winding to the frame. They say little about insulation between turns of a coil: a shorted turn does not leak to ground, so a winding can pass and still have one. They do not find a broken rotor bar, a worn bearing or a loose wedge. Penrose points out that IEEE 43 and IEEE 95 give basic go or no-go information and no guidance on extracting more from a DC test. Megger notes that some materials show so little dielectric absorption that their PI comes out very close to 1. Pair the test with vibration, thermography and, for important machines, surge and partial discharge testing.

Where It Fits in Your Maintenance Plan

A turbine generator's winding test belongs on the outage calendar, next to the work in our steam turbine maintenance guide. A diesel alternator that stands idle for months, especially in a damp climate, belongs on its maintenance schedule. A pump motor is a third common use, and our guide to solar water pump repair covers the motor and its cable joints. A submersible tested in the well works to its maker's own limits, which that guide gives.

Make the first test a baseline and set the date for the next. Decide the voltage and the correction method once and write them down. Investigate any corrected reading under its minimum, or any decline from the last two tests, before the machine goes back into service.

MIMAH's maintenance team carries out preventive maintenance and diagnostics on rotating equipment. If you have a winding with a falling trend, a wet machine, or a test report you are not sure how to read, get in touch.